October 8, 2021
Magicians The Shocker, Magic Maxl, Jeki Yoo, and Ben Seidman try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions. Scott Wolf helps with a trick.

Episode 3
Happy Birthday!
October 15, 2021
Magicians Amanda Nepo, Shoot Ogawa, Ale Belotto & Guilia, and Mark Clearview try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions. A special guest appearance by Judy Gold.

Episode 4
Monkeys, Donuts and X-Men
October 22, 2021
Magicians Anchal Kumawat, Mark Doetsch, Michael O’Brien, and Adrian Cárratalá try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.

Episode 5
Teller Gets Whacked!
November 5, 2021
Magicians Alex Ramon, Micah, Cameron Young, and Matthew Teague try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.

Episode 6
Penn & Tizzle
November 12, 2021
Magicians Leroya Sanford, Joshua Jay, Gabriel Gascon, and Luca Volpe try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.

Episode 7
Rock Paper Magic!
November 19, 2021
Magicians Hayden Childress, Hans, Benjamin Barnes, and Jay & Joss try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.

Episode 8
Magic Cubed
December 3, 2021
Magicians Sydney Weaver, Steven Palmore, Danny Ray, and Bobby Torkova try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.

Episode 9
Chocolate Magic
January 7, 2022
Magicians Tori Noquez, Alex Boyer, Andi Gladwin, and Topas try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions. Heather McDonald helps with a magic trick.

Episode 10
The Penn-Tagram
January 14, 2022
Magicians Mellow, Paige Thompson, Stanley Zhou, and Jonathon Lachance try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.

Episode 11
Stabba Dabba Deck
January 21, 2022
Magicians Zak Mirz, John-Henry, Andy Deemer, and Thomas Solomon try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.

Episode 12
P&T's Big Game Halftime Show
January 28, 2022
Magicians Rick Smith Jr. & Rokas, Lindsey Noel, Jason Suran, and Roddy McGhie try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.

Episode 13
Penn on Fire
February 25, 2022
Magicians John Fitzsimmons, David Corsaro, Bentley Burns, and Diego & Elena try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.

Episode 14
Ghostbusters
March 4, 2022
Magicians Sean-Paul & Juliana Fay, Disguido, Dr. Scott Kahn, and Star Newman try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.